Best practices in data management and privacy mandate that old data must be irreversibly destroyed. However, due to performance optimization reasons, old (deleted or updated) data is not immediately purged from active database storage. Database backups that typically work by backing up table and index pages (rather than logical rows) greatly exacerbate the privacy problem of the old surviving data. Copying such deleted data into backups ensures that unknown quantities of old data can be stored indefinitely.In this paper, we quantify the amount of deleted data retained in backups by four major representative databases, comparing the default behavior versus an explicit defrag operation. We review the defrag options available in these databases and discuss the impact they have on eliminating old data from backups. We demonstrate that each database has a defrag mechanism that can eliminate most of old deleted data (although in Oracle pre-update content may survive defrag). Finally, we outline the factors that organizations should consider when deciding whether to apply defrag prior to executing their backups.